Is This Whisper Man 2.0?

filled star filled star filled star filled star filled star
melliesligh Avatar

By

You might have removed yourself from the game, he seemed to be saying. But the game isn’t finished with you yet.

When reading The Shadows, I put aside the thought of, “Is this better than The Whisper Man?” I wanted to be able to review it as a stand alone, away from North’s previous hit. This task was very hard to do.

If this was any other author, I would have said yes this is amazing and creepy! I need another nightlight because I cannot sleep. If I compare this to North’s previous, I would say this is just like The Whsiper Man 2.0. I can definitely see the parallels vividly in this book. I said I wanted to review this as a stand alone, but it is SO HARD to do that when the comparisons to The Whisper Man are right there in front of your face.

I will say I was confused for the first 1/3 of the book. Am I to believe this is truly real? Or, is this another fictional character that is an urban legend that is pretending to be real? I couldn’t see a clear path in the woods (haha, pun intended) on where this was going.

This book was actually kind of sad. There are 3 cases of two schoolmates killing a third and that’s what Dectice Amanda Beck is trying to see if there’s a link. It’s just sad that someone would groom another just to kill them at such a young age. I wish they would have given a little bit more of Beck’s past to help me connect more. However, the concept of lucid dreams and being awake while asleep scared the mess out of me. I was pretty scared to have a wonderful dream.

I enjoyed The Shadows, regardless if it was very comparable to The Whisper Man. I honestly like these urban legend type books and have been drawn to them recently.

4.5 stars for The Shadows, coming out 07.09.2020. Thank you Celadon & Bookish First for the gifted copy.