I was already convinced at "Gossip Girl meets One of Us Is Lying" because I love both of those, and after reading the First Look, I'm desperate to finish this novel! The characters and basic setup aren't new or earth-shattering, but there's a reason I keep reading the books like this -- they're fascinating no matter how many different iterations I see of them. I am definitely hooked already, and this is the kind of book that circulates quickly around my school library, so I'm excited to read the whole thing and recommend it to my students.