Bright ideas and an easily engaging writing style, but mixed feelings about some aspects.
The Silent Patient has a fantastic premise and a writing style that is simple yet enthralling and easy to get into. I was very quickly immersed into the storyline after just a few pages in and interested to see how it would all unfold.
When weak points started to emerge by the quarter to halfway point, the prevailing mystery already had its hooks in me. This resulted in a dogged determination to see how it would all end and what the larger truth is among a flurry of suspicious-seeming characters and situations.
Our story follows two characters. The main narrative voice is Theo, a criminal psychologist and therapist. He reads as young and not entirely convincing for much of the book. His personal relationships are strained and frankly, he does not come off as a character who could convince the powers that be that he is stable and thoughtful enough to fulfill his obligations. I had to suspend some disbelief to process that and had mixed feelings for the character overall. He is well-realized but there are definitely some noticeable weak points in the portrayal of him as well-versed in criminology and psychology.
The patients and doctors and the ways they relate could also be alarming, I often felt like the patients were almost like projects and sometimes treated inhumanely. Multiple doctors speak sweepingly about some mental illnesses in a way that seemed questionable. But for full disclosure- I don't have a background in the fields on display here. Just as a casual observer, something didn't sit consistently right about the portrayal(s) here.
Now for the next main character, Alicia. In short, she killed her husband (this is revealed almost instantly into the novel) and has since become mute. She is a conundrum to all who try to communicate with her. The motive behind her actions is murky and leads down an ominous path where each question leads to even more questions, down a rabbit hole of possibilities. We learn of her story when Theo goes full-on detective mode to investigate the events leading up to that fateful night. He meets people she knew, each one inspiring uncertainty. The truth about what happened to Alicia and her husband is at the heart of the story and I found it to be quite a captivating question.
Along the way we find out the gist of all the relationships involved and events that led to the murder, layer by layer. There are also numerous journal entries that were written by a much more lucid Alicia in years prior. These go far in shedding light upon her psyche and hint toward a more nuanced explanation for everything.
So without further ado, here were my thoughts on the ending. Still aiming to be spoiler-free but you may want to stop reading here if you don't want any inkling of how it ends. I just think that when it comes to suspense/thrillers/mysteries, knowing whether the ending is satisfying or not is so important since the whole point of books in these genre(s) are often wrapped up within that payoff.
In my opinion most questions were answered and the big whodunnit reveal, while not a gasp-worthy surprise (and I kind of guessed it early on but only as a passive thought) was probably the best way to end this story. For how much info was given on all the suspects, any other solution might have been far less interesting. Also of note is that the ending does supply some re-read potential, which is rare. A second read of The Silent Patient would probably be quite different and make me think more analytically about everything that occurred.
I'm giving this book 4 stars, but would place it on the lower end of 4. In comparison to other books in similar genres that I've read this year it places below The Turn of the Key by Ruth Ware and Big Little Lies by Liane Moriarty, but a bit above Pretty Girls by Karin Slaughter. Expected a more jaw-dropping experience given the hype and widespread popularity of this title.
When weak points started to emerge by the quarter to halfway point, the prevailing mystery already had its hooks in me. This resulted in a dogged determination to see how it would all end and what the larger truth is among a flurry of suspicious-seeming characters and situations.
Our story follows two characters. The main narrative voice is Theo, a criminal psychologist and therapist. He reads as young and not entirely convincing for much of the book. His personal relationships are strained and frankly, he does not come off as a character who could convince the powers that be that he is stable and thoughtful enough to fulfill his obligations. I had to suspend some disbelief to process that and had mixed feelings for the character overall. He is well-realized but there are definitely some noticeable weak points in the portrayal of him as well-versed in criminology and psychology.
The patients and doctors and the ways they relate could also be alarming, I often felt like the patients were almost like projects and sometimes treated inhumanely. Multiple doctors speak sweepingly about some mental illnesses in a way that seemed questionable. But for full disclosure- I don't have a background in the fields on display here. Just as a casual observer, something didn't sit consistently right about the portrayal(s) here.
Now for the next main character, Alicia. In short, she killed her husband (this is revealed almost instantly into the novel) and has since become mute. She is a conundrum to all who try to communicate with her. The motive behind her actions is murky and leads down an ominous path where each question leads to even more questions, down a rabbit hole of possibilities. We learn of her story when Theo goes full-on detective mode to investigate the events leading up to that fateful night. He meets people she knew, each one inspiring uncertainty. The truth about what happened to Alicia and her husband is at the heart of the story and I found it to be quite a captivating question.
Along the way we find out the gist of all the relationships involved and events that led to the murder, layer by layer. There are also numerous journal entries that were written by a much more lucid Alicia in years prior. These go far in shedding light upon her psyche and hint toward a more nuanced explanation for everything.
So without further ado, here were my thoughts on the ending. Still aiming to be spoiler-free but you may want to stop reading here if you don't want any inkling of how it ends. I just think that when it comes to suspense/thrillers/mysteries, knowing whether the ending is satisfying or not is so important since the whole point of books in these genre(s) are often wrapped up within that payoff.
In my opinion most questions were answered and the big whodunnit reveal, while not a gasp-worthy surprise (and I kind of guessed it early on but only as a passive thought) was probably the best way to end this story. For how much info was given on all the suspects, any other solution might have been far less interesting. Also of note is that the ending does supply some re-read potential, which is rare. A second read of The Silent Patient would probably be quite different and make me think more analytically about everything that occurred.
I'm giving this book 4 stars, but would place it on the lower end of 4. In comparison to other books in similar genres that I've read this year it places below The Turn of the Key by Ruth Ware and Big Little Lies by Liane Moriarty, but a bit above Pretty Girls by Karin Slaughter. Expected a more jaw-dropping experience given the hype and widespread popularity of this title.