Exciting premise, bland characters.

filled star filled star filled star star unfilled star unfilled
booksfromavirgo Avatar

By

The Good Luck Girls is a YA fantasy following a group of girls who escape from a "Welcome House" (a brothel) after one of them accidentally kills a client. Now they are constantly on the run, and some of them are out for revenge.

The Good Luck Girls is Charlotte Nicole Davis's debut novel, and simultaneously unique and common. Because it was a debut, it displayed the problems many debuts have: underdeveloped characters, predictability, you know the deal.

But The Good Luck Girls was so much more than that, despite the flaws! The premise and world were unique and the worldbuilding was done very well. The story takes place in a fantastical version of the American West, and those vibes were very much felt.

Another thing that set apart this book was its diversity. The main character, Aspen, was black, and most main characters were PoC, but the "PoC-ness" didn't matter to the story, it was just there. So, amazing casual diversity! Additionally, Aspen did not have a love interest, which is a rarity in YA novels...This meant that there was no romance to detract from the protagonist's story. But! The other main characters had their romances, and these included f/m and f/f. So again, props.

One last thing, trigger warnings (and here I must warn of minor spoilers): Because of the nature of this book, I want to warn potential readers about sexual assault/attempted rape, graphic violence, addiction, and murder.