Poignant Whimsy

filled star filled star filled star filled star star unfilled
imlisaann Avatar

By

The Dinner List was a Book of the Month pick for August and comes out on September 11th. I hemmed and hawed over my box last month, trying to decide which books I wanted to get. I actually hemmed and hawed so much that other people in a BOTM Facebook group I'm in received their books and started talking about them. I try to make my BOTM picks books I think I will want to re-read since I'm making the splurge and getting them in a physical copy. The Dinner List is lighter than my usual BOTM fare and yet I'm glad I took a chance and picked it as an extra. I picked it up last weekend in the middle of two crazy weeks at work and it was exactly the distraction I needed.

The premise is fairly simple and reminiscent of an icebreaker game you were probably forced to play at summer camp--name any five people, living or dead, you'd like to have dinner with. Thus begins Sabrina's thirtieth birthday with her best friend, Audrey Hepburn, her ex-boyfriend Tobias, and a few others. Serle does an excellent job weaving the connections to Audrey Hepburn into the book so that the choice of Ms. Hepburn at the table feels less random than it could, or the throwaway choice every girl who had A Breakfast at Tiffany's poster on her dorm room wall would make (guilty as charged). And, as Anne Bogel noted, Audrey makes it work--she brings levity and a bit of magical whimsy to otherwise heavy moments, yet her own actual tragic history brings perspective to others.

I went into The Dinner List wanted an easy escape read and discovered a surprisingly poignant gem. The writing gave me the easy escape I wanted, the premise made the plot move fast enough to stay compelling, and the characters made me care deeply for each of them. The Dinner List probes the reasons people leave, why certain people seem drawn to our lives, and what it means to let go.