I can see a lot of people liking this, just not me.

This book will be a big hit with a certain reader, but that reader is not me. There is something about anyone pining over a high school love and imagining that it was perfect or they were somehow better that really rubs me wrong. From what I got from this narrative in particular was that the female lead was being seen as some sort of pixie dream girl that got away. Nope, not interested.