First off I lovee how this book is set up. I feel like on of the dectatives figuring out what happened in the on that night. Looking at testimonies, video evidence and so much more. There were some really good twists in there that I half way excepted. The world of this book was set up really well with the riddles at each stage of the forest. I do have to say that there were too many characters in this book and it was extremely hard to keep track of all of them. In that there was a hinder in character development for most of the characters leaving them unnecessary for the story. I feel like the author was trying to represent everyone and missed on what could make the story better. I was also expecting more from the ending but was a little confused. Overall I think that this book is has an incredibly unique set up but overall missed the mark on what could have been a timeless book