Grey's "twin flame" Elora disappeared one night while out with her friends in the swamp and no one has seen her since. The town where she is from is known for its psychic community, and all her friends have some sort of gift, except Grey. But she's been having flashes of her friend Elora from that night, even though she wasn't there. Could she actually still be alive? Is the murderer they tell stories in the dark about back? Or did he never leave?