Where do I even start!? I absolutely loved this book and I want there to be a sequel so bad! The writing is magnificent and some of the analogies she made blew me away. This book made me really stop and think about the choices I’m making in my life and if I’m acting on the goals and dreams I have for my life. This book had so many wonderful messages in it. It also has LDS rep and that is so amazing!! I’m LDS and it was so cool seeing it represented well by a non LDS author. At first I didn’t like how she did the Wish History sections but as I kept reading I started to really enjoy it and it brought a fresh new perspective to the book. The characters were amazing and I really enjoyed that in the end, the main character didn’t get the girl or everything he wanted. I also loved Merrill and Eldon’s friendship. Just everything about this book is so amazing!! I’m still conflicted about the ending but I think that that’s a good thing because I like it when author’s don’t give the reader everything they predict or want. I thought when I started reading this book that I had it all figured out and predicted but I was so wrong and I’m so happy because the twists and turns made the book so good!! I really enjoy unpredictable books.