So I did not finish the book. And it greatly saddens me. I try not to but it just didnt hold my interest. And I'm not saying anything bad. It could be me. But I didnt hold my attention. It felt to wishy washy to me. And it didnt have to much action in the story. I wasnt attached to any of the characters or the story. I know some may not feel the same way. But I just felt myself pushing to finish. I did enjoy tho that they were doing a then and now set. But I just felt it may have been better described. I felt it was missing something. I'm still going to look out for him. Because I did enjoy The whisper man. That held more depth and detail. So I may have had my expectations for this book to high.