Definitely a solid four stars. Only in that the beginning was very confusing. I also didn't really understand what was going on at first. eventually though I got into the book and I did enjoy it a lot. I think my english teacher at the time gave me a pretty good recommendation. I honestly like it there were a few flaws and confusing bits but the other interesting parts made up for it. on a side note I also really love the cover its so beautiful and really shows off what the book is about. This book has a pretty good age range it as well ranging from middle school reader to young adult. Im not sure but maybe some adults would enjoy this book as well definitely a good read to pick up sometimes for a good read.