I'm leaving this at a 3, because while it wasn't my flavor of tea, it was still pretty beautifully written. If you're looking for a fast paced whodunnit, this ain't it. It's a slow burn that takes a look at Claire, a 7 year old who lost her sister to (homicide, an accident?) while on a private resort vacation. While I could call the writing sublime, it was ultimately kinda pointless and nothing like I was anticipating. This book could have been halved and told the same story. I skimmed the last 20 pages because I just couldnt stand to have this same island described for the 40th time. That's really all I have to say about this book, this is the end of my review...…………………......………...………………...