This YA story appears to come from a"what if" based on a story in the news where one child accidentally killed another by using wrestling moves he saw on television without understands the dangers inherent in using these moves. After all, on wrestling on TV the other guy always got up. So, what if the victims of these accidents, or their families, could decide the punishment of the offender? Would that improve the results? Let's read this story and see what the author thinks.